What’s the Difference: Pine Sap, Pitch, or Resin?

As I was writing an article for the About.com Survival Skills website on the topic of how to make a pine pitch torch, I was confronted by many different terms: sap, pitch, resin, tar, among others. Most people seem to use these words interchangeably, but I wanted to know more about what they’re supposed to mean, so here’s what I can gather:

Sap: more of a liquid, like honey or less viscous than honey. Sap is the sugary secretion from plants as well as trees (think raw material for maple syrup).

Pine Sap Drop

Pitch: think of an intermediate between a liquid and a complete solid. Pitch is like that crystallized honey you find in your pantry after it’s been there for quite a while.

Pine Pitch

Resin: usually refers to the most solid of all these forms. If you’ve played an instrument with a bow (like the violin), you’ve probably used a solid block of resin on your bow, as in the photo below right. People seem to use “pitch” and “resin” more interchangeably, while sap usage is reserved more often for the seeping, liquid form.

violin resin

Now that you’ve got the terminology straight, check out my article on the About.com Survival Skills website:

“How to Make a Pine Pitch Torch”

Photos:
1. © Flickr® user Ian.
2. © Flickr® user Petr Gladkikh.
3. © Flickr® user McBeth.

Advertisements

12 responses to “What’s the Difference: Pine Sap, Pitch, or Resin?

  1. Not quite. Sap is the plant equivalent of blood in animals- it’s water-based, and it circulates though the body bringing nutrients to tissues and carrying away waste products.

    In contrast, pitch is hydrocarbon-based and sits static in special vessels, mainly in the outermost wood layers. Its function is defensive; when a grub chews though the tissues where the pitch vessels are located, the pitch oozes out of the severed vessels and actually pushes the grub clear out the hole where it came in, at least if the tree is healthy enough to produce a lot of pitch. Resin is more like crystallized pitch that’s lost its lighter, more liquid components.

    Just because everyone and their uncle uses “sap” and “pitch” as synonyms doesn’t mean that they’re right. It *is* possible for something that ‘everyone knows’ to actually be flat-out wrong.

  2. Thanks for the clarification, Bill, but no need to be a rude snob…!

    • Sorry you took it that way, Colby.

      My point at the end is that nearly all of us (myself certainly included) get led astray now and then by “common knowledge”. Most people have no way of knowing about the difference between pitch and sap unless they happen to stumble upon it by accident, and in the meantime they keep hearing the wrong info on this question from trusted sources around them. That’s life.

      I’m no better than anyone else- I just know a few different things than you or the next person, and probably get a few different things wrong that you don’t.

  3. Thanks for this article, and Bill, I appreciate your addition! As a scientist, I appreciate the addition of ecological function to the discussion–it helps me to remember pitch versus sap, just by thinking of the grub-eject response. Didn’t seem snobby to me, just more stuff to help understand how the pine-trees respond.

    I’m hoping to experiment with the tree across the street and I want to be sure I don’t injure the tree or open it up to insect invasion. Any additional information on how to treat the tree after cutting into bark layers would be very welcome! (Yes, I did look at your other article on making pine-pitch–didn’t see any info on protecting the tree. Sorry if I missed it.) Advice?

    • Wolfonakayak, my understanding is that treatment is not recommended. Long ago gardeners painted pruning wounds with special paint, but that turned out to do more harm than good. You just have to let the tree heal itself. The main problem is if the tree is weakened, like by drought, and can’t defend itself adequately against pests and diseases. Best to not cause any wounds unless you really need to, like when doing corrective pruning.

      • Thanks, Bill. I have a tree in mind to collect a bit of sap, resin, or pitch from, but I think I’ll just try “attacking” a smaller limb, since I don’t need to extract that much for the purpose of learning how it’s done. It should be easier for the tree to heal if I cut the limb off when I’m finished, leaving a neater, smaller wound to heal.

        While it should be really freakin’ cold here in Southern Wisconsin, it’s not (hello, climate-change) and a lot of sap is running early due to the intermittent spurts of 40 to 55 degree weather. I can probably be in and out by the end of March, so the injury is protectively covered with resin before the summer arrives. The El Nino often leaves the Midwest with a hot, dry summer the following year, so I do fear drought.

        After reading this and several other articles about pine-pitch, I watched some YouTube videos, and most of them were hideous so far as the care of the tree goes. Maybe that works in Northern Wisconsin’s pine forests, but down here, with the largely deciduous forests, I’m not going to treat any tree as a disposable object.

        Then I came across the care of the pine-pitch forests in France, established by Napoleon and well-tended from then until Cyclone Kraus destroyed much of the forest in 2009. That’s a LONG time to develop skills of taking pitch from trees without killing them. I’m going to use their methods, for sure!

  4. Not to pile on with the nitpicking, but resin and pitch are the same thing. The solid form is called rosin.

  5. voodoochili
    your answer is more pertinent to the answer I was seeking (by Googling), which was the difference between resin and rosin and what is pine gum (pitch?). ultimately, I was attempting to find out what pine tar is made from and there are so many products with different descriptions using all of the terms above depending on the manufacturer. I’m a country girl, but we just called it pitch. does anyone know which pine element is in pine tar (besides beeswax and some type of oil)? I have seen everything from that it’s derived from processed pine gum to the residue left from burning pine wood.

  6. Pingback: Finding and Using Fire Starting Materials in the Wilderness - Survive!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s